When you love both shots, compare more clearly
Expressions, poses and details often reveal themselves in the small differences between two photos. View them together and choose the one that best expresses what this set is about.
Expressions first, details next
Bring similar photos together and look at expressions and poses. Side-by-side viewing makes differences easier to notice than switching back and forth.
Look at the whole frame
After inspecting the details, return to the full frame. Does the composition feel natural? Do the person and their surroundings relate in the way you intended?
Let your choices serve the story
Keep more than one photo if it helps, and revisit photos that weren't initially selected. Don't lose a moment that moves you just to reduce the count.